MathiasCavanaugh.com

A fantasy & science fiction writer's blog by author Mathias Cavanaugh
  • Home
  • Home
  • Novels
    • Daughters of Fate Book 1
    • Daughters of Fate Book 2
    • Daughters of Fate Book 3
  • About Mathias Cavanaugh
  • Info For Literary Agents/Publishers
  • Contact Mathias
Home > Book Reviews, General Things > Giving Your Own Book A Five Star Rating Is Just Outlandish

Giving Your Own Book A Five Star Rating Is Just Outlandish

January 13, 2013 Mathias Leave a comment Go to comments

Some people have no shame.  I see it all the time with authors who give their own book a “5 star” rating on Goodreads and other, similar sites.

And the worst part about it is that they aren’t even shy about it.  They plop it up there and are almost so proud that they are beaming with joy over their actions.

Does any author really not like their own work?  If they don’t, they why are they publishing it?  It is sort of implied that, when an author publishes a book, they think it is a great story that other people should read.  But to advertise this by giving it a rating in such a bold manner is, frankly, outlandish behaviour that to me borders on narcissism.   Especially when you consider how willing other people are to give even average works five stars whether for free, for a little quid pro quo, or even for money.

Not that there is anything wrong with being average mind you.  Average is neither great nor horrible.  It’s just … well … average.  Lots of people are average.  Lots of things are average.  And believe me, lots of “5 star” books are very much average.

I’d really like to see authors stop giving their own works five star reviews on public sites and forums.  It just doesn’t seem right.  Besides, everyone knows the author is biased towards their own work.  So does anyone really take these sorts of reviews/ratings seriously anyway?  I know I don’t.  Look, it’s one thing to talk up you own work and promote yourself.  It is another matter entirely to actually rank your own work with a “5 star” review.

The best way to toot your own horn is to let someone else blow it for you.  When you resort to blowing it yourself you only seem desperate.

Categories: Book Reviews, General Things Tags: 5 Star, Advertise, Authors, Borders, Five Stars, Forums, Goodreads, Money, Narcissism, Rating People, Shame, Similar Sites, Sorts, Star Books, Star People, Star Rating, Star Reviews, Toot Your Own Horn
Comments (0) Trackbacks (0) Leave a comment Trackback
  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hello There! Long Time No Post! Let The Submission Process Begin!!!

Let’s Connect!

Follow Me on FacebookFollow Me on TwitterFollow Me on LinkedInFollow Me on PinterestFollow Me on RSSFollow Me on Goodreads

Subscribe to My Newsletter

We keep your data private and share your data only with third parties that make this service possible. Read our Privacy Policy.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Read Books by Mathias Cavanaugh

AVAILABLE NOW ON WATTPAD!

Daughters of Fate Book 1
Daughters of Fate Book 2
Daughters of Fate Book 3

Tales of the Inglorious Brotherhood (In Progress)

Recent Posts

  • Getting Your Writing Done: Burst and Session Writing
  • Daughters of Fate (The Completed Trilogy)
  • Why Twitter Is A Dangerous Place For Me To Be
  • The Little Author Who Cried, “Woe Was Me!”
  • When In Doubt, Blow Something Up!

Categories

Archives

Writing Projects:

Novels:
Under the Darkened Moon (Final Manuscript)
100%
Outsider (1st Draft)
90%
Cry of the Golden Wyvern (1st Draft)
15%
Awakening (1st Draft)
55%
Dragon's Tale (1st Draft)
15%
Her Lovely Blood (1st Draft)
20%
The Half-Orc Princess (1st Draft)
15%
The Stone-Flesh Curse (1st Draft)
10%
Wildflower's Rebellion (Concept)
0%

Short Stories:
Second Chances (Final Manuscript)
100%
The Yoke (Final Manuscript 2nd Take)
100%
First and Second Lessons (3rd Polish Edit)
88%
Sacrifice (Manuscript)
90%
The Flames (5th Polish Edit)
100%

Top
Copyright © 2011-2021 MathiasCavanaugh.com